Item Coversheet
Item #1.

Staff Report: 001-24

TO:

Mayor and City Council




FROM:

Eric Holmes, City Manager




DATE:

1/8/2024








SUBJECT


Bid Rejection - Bid #23-44: Sewage Lift Pump for Vancouver Marine Park Wastewater Treatment Facility
Key Points
  • City staff is recommending Council reject all bids received for the ITB 23-44: Sewage Lift Pump for Vancouver Marine Park Wastewater Treatment Facility (WWTF).
  • One bid was received on October 26, 2023, and it was 9.4 times higher than the Engineer’s Estimate. This project was bid as a goods only purchase of two sewage lift pumps.
  • Bid rejection will allow the project to pursue competitive pricing by establishing more standard requirements and specifications, which should allow more vendors to bid.

Strategic Plan Alignment
Safe and Prepared Community – a safe place to live, work, learn, and play.
Present Situation

The influent sewage lift pumps are a critical infrastructure component to Vancouver’s wastewater treatment services. The Marine Park WWTF sewage influent pump gallery contains two newer non-clog pumps and three pumps from original construction in the 1990’s. The three older pumps clog with wipes and debris within two days of operation and require treatment plant operators to manually remove the material from pumps. Replacement of two of the larger old pumps with newer non-clog pumps is necessary to ensure a safer workplace and more reliable operation.

 

This project was bid on October 26, 2023, for the purchase of two Sewage Lift Pumps for Vancouver’s Marine Park WWTF. One bid was received and opened.  The bid was $862,969.30 which is 9.5 times higher than the published engineer’s estimate of $90,000.

 

SUMMARY OF BIDS

BIDDER

AMOUNT

Whitney Equipment, Woodinville, WA

$862,969.30

Engineer’s Estimate (as published)

$90,000

Updated Estimate

$560,000

 

The engineer’s estimate (as published) was based on a single, smaller pump. The estimate was erroneously not updated when the project turned to pursuing larger pumps.

 

Staff and their consultant engineer are evaluating pump specifications and bid requirements to ensure cost-effective and competitive prices for the purchase of these replacement pumps. 


Advantage(s)

Re-bidding the project will allow staff to ensure more competitive pricing by establishing more standard requirements and specifications.


Disadvantage(s)
  1. Additional administrative costs associated with rebidding the project.
  2. Delays the purchase of the Sewage Lift Pump.

Budget Impact

The Marine Park Influent Pump Replacement project is programmed into the 2024 Sewer Treatment Capital budget as project PRJ100878.


Prior Council Review

Approved in the 2023-2024 Sewer Treatment Capital Budget.


Action Requested

On January 8, 2024, reject all bids to allow staff to pursue competitive purchase of pumps for Marine Park Wastewater Treatment Facility.

 

Frank Dick, Senior Civil Engineer, 360-487-7179